The Auto Repair Industry (Part 1)

The Auto Repair Industry (Part 1)

Consumers should be aware of how the auto repair industry works. When you bring  your vehicle to an auto repair shop and enter the office, you_re usually greeted by a  service writer. It doesn_t matter if you go to a dealership, a franchised shop (like Midas  or Firestone), or a small independent shop -- more often than not, the service writer is  the first person you meet. The service writer acts as an intermediary between you and  the repair technician. He tells the technician to inspect the car, the technician informs  him what the findings are, and then he comes back to you with the findings. Some  shops allow the customer to come into the repair room to see the technician_s findings,  but many don_t. 
 
The service writer is evaluated by upper management, which may include the manager  of the shop, a director of one or many shops, and/or the owner. The owners of large  shops are not usually onsite and function mostly as investors. They_re hoping to make a  return on their investment. Directors may manage multiple shops or be the head of an entire department, such as the service department at a dealership.

Since the service writer is a middleman between the customer and the technician, there  are frequent communication problems that can occur. A customer may come into the  shop and say that the car makes a squeaking sound when the brakes are applied. The  service writer thinks it_s the brake pads, so he tells the technician to inspect the brake  pads. There may be nothing wrong with the brake pads. What the service writer should  have done is write down that there is a squeaking sound when the brakes are applied.  Then the technician can diagnose the problem better. Similar communication issues can  also occur in the other direction. The technician may explain problems or findings to the  service writer and the service writer may fail to relay the information correctly to the customer.

The service writer is first and foremost a salesman, not a technician. His knowledge and  understanding of how a vehicle works is often not any greater than the customer_s.  Some service writers can be very knowledgeable about cars; others are not. In either  case, when the customer speaks to him, he will appear to understand what is wrong  with the vehicle. 
 
A major problem with the entire industry, from the technicians to upper management, is  that everyone is paid on commission. This means that they are motivated and rewarded  to increase sales and raise the price in order to make more money. The services that  they suggest are often not damaging to the car; they_re just not necessary. They may say that your cooling system needs a flush when it doesn_t or they could fudge the  numbers on maintenance intervals to increase the frequency of services. Maintenance  services are often based on mileage, so it_s easy for a shop to say that a service is  required at 30,000 miles when it actually isn_t due until 90,000 miles. By changing the  interval to every 30,000 miles, they sell the service three times instead of one. This is  why it is important to review the maintenance chart in the owner_s manual of the vehicle.  Also, some repairs are needed at an earlier time than what is specified in the owner_s  manual. This will be based on certain conditions which can include the weather, the  driving route, the driver_s habits, and other environmental conditions where the vehicle  is driven or parked on a regular basis.

Comments